Sunday, September 29, 2013

Armageddon's Prisoners 3

Unlike the austere Gathering Houses Disciples used around the world, the Apostle’s conference room contained only the best appointments.  Where Houses had cheap plastic chairs and inexpensive carpet, this room boasted deep Italian leather chairs surrounding a polished granite table.  The building, built as a luxury hotel, never saw its intended use.  The First Apostle bought the property to use as the Foundation’s headquarters. The Apostles still preserved the hardwood floors, delicate filigree head rails, and window casings.

Laban Packard looked out the windows for a moment, watching a seaplane speed across Lake Union to take off.  Although he knew the plane made a tremendous noise, no sound penetrated the thick glass, rumored to be bulletproof.  Some days, soundproof glass seemed like a good idea. 

“John,” he said mildly, “could you at least stop swearing, it’s unseemly.”

Out of the corner of his eye, he saw Doug Sadler nod vigorously.  Doug, the oldest of the twelve men around the table, disliked many of John Rodgers’ habits, although they were friends.  At seventy-four, John was only a couple of years younger than Doug.  Eleven of the twelve men were over sixty. 

“I’m Chief Apostle!” Rodgers snapped, “I’ll talk any way I Goddamn well please.”

Laban saw Peter McCarrick, sitting across the table suppress a smile, “John, the office of Chief Apostle no longer exists.”

Rodgers faced turned even redder.  Laban tried to think of reason to excuse himself, he expected the meeting to get even uglier.  Rodgers, as if by magic changed his mood.  The people working with him soon grew accustomed to his sudden mood shifts. 

“You’re right, I really need to keep my emotions in check.”  He scanned the table smiling, “I’m sorry, I was out of hand.”

His attention turned to the empty seats, normally occupied by aides and secretaries, lining the walls of the room. 

“Well, I guess it’s a good thing we’re in executive session, no witnesses.” 

He laughed mirthlessly at his own joke. 

“So let’s get back to work.”

“As I was saying,” David Howell continued, “I think we need to find a way to make the Disciples understand there is nothing fundamentally wrong with our interpretation of Bible prophecy.  It is clear that we are well into the Last Days.  Surely the great day of The Lord is not far off. 

“I regret my part in promoting the 2011 date, I still think the calculations are correct.  I’m continuing my research, perhaps my mistake involves lunar versus solar years…”

“And that brings us back to my point,” Philip Hogeboom snapped, “what if we’re wrong?”
Laban nodded, Phil was the real scholar among the Apostles.  He read Greek, Hebrew and Latin with a reasonable degree of fluency, something none of the others could claim. 

“We can’t be wrong,” Robert Olzak interjected, “clearly The Lord has placed us here to lead His people through the End into Paradise.”

“That’s circular reasoning.  “We lead in the time of the end, we’re leading so this is the time of the end.’  We’ll never get off this merry-go-round if we don’t change our approach.”
Laban looked up in surprise, Peter McCarrick focused on business aspects of the Foundation, he rarely involved himself in theological debates.  His motivation became apparent with his next words.

“I agree, the coming Paradise is a fundamental feature of The Lord’s Word.  However, it is not the only feature.  Our Disciple-making methods are no longer effective in today’s world.  We should branch out into modern media.  Instead of telling our young people to avoid college and career we should encourage them to pursue financially rewarding lives and donate more money to the Foundation.”

McCarrick’s eyes swept the table, taking in the reflexive disagreement of most of his colleagues.  The Foundation had long discouraged education and career as distractions from the commission to make Disciples.

“Look how well it’s worked for the Mormons…”

“Damn it,” Rodgers went off again, “I’m not going to take my example of leadership from a bunch of crazy cultists.  What’s next? Recruit Hollywood harlots like Scientology?”

David Howell grinned, for a moment breaking out of the funk that had consumed him since 2011 came and went with no Armageddon.

“I don’t know John, ‘Hollywood Harlots’ has a nice ring to it.”

For a moment, Laban thought Rodgers’ head would explode.  But after a moment, he too joined in the laughter.

“Well we’re not going to set a new strategic direction for the Foundation today.  Let’s all jot down some thoughts on the matter and we’ll take it up next week.  We can call in the others and start our regular session.”
**

That evening Laban stopped by Phil’s living quarters for a private chat.  Phil’s wife said he was in the library.  Laban took the walkway over the street that connected the Apostle’s space with the administrative annex housing the library.  He found Phil in his favorite location, the ancient language section.  Laban was sure that nobody else used the small room with Greek and Hebrew texts.

“Good evening, Phil, what are you doing in here?”

“Thinking.”

“Do we still do that?”

“Well,” Phil said sarcastically, “somebody has to.  We’ve  trained the Disciples not to do it for themselves.”

For several minutes, the two men talked about the current state of affairs at the Foundation without discovering anything new.  Both expressed concern over the rot and disinterest in the religion’s core.  The failure of the 2011 prophetic interpretation provided ample ammunition for the Word’s critics, and the Disciples had no idea what happened to the hope they had chased for many years.

“I’m hearing about more and more problems in the local Gatherings,” Laban noted, “people are getting crazy.  Just this morning I got a letter about three Servants in New York running an investment scam.  And another letter about possible wife swapping in a Gathering in California.

“That’s not how the Lord’s people are supposed to behave.  And it’s our fault.  We told them the world was about to end, that they would be living in Paradise with a thing to worry about.  We told them we had all the answers, now they have no idea how to live.”

Laban had no idea how to answer that.  It was all true.
**

John Rodgers and David Howell sat in the corner of John’s living room, a small conversation nook nestled between two large windows with panoramic views of Seattle. 
The city blazed with light, which shimmered on the water of Lake Union.  The Space Needle towered to the west.  Neither man looked at the view.

The two sat on small couches facing each other over a low coffee table.  Two glass of scotch sat on coasters.  John preferred to talk over drinks late at night.  His associates were used to it.  Although officially the position no longer meant anything, most Disciples still thought of him as “Chief 
Apostle.”  Certainly he thought of himself that way.

“David, we need to get the Disciples whipped back into shape.  None of this ‘lighten the load’ nonsense weaklings like Packard and his friends keep prattling on about.”
Howell nodded, but said nothing.  These conversations went better if the “Chief” did most of the talking.

“I mean it, and this is no criticism of you.  They got all worked up about this date and forgot about serving the Lord.  We never said 2011 would see Paradise restored.  We only suggested that it would be a logical time.  Next thing you know, people are selling houses, cashing in retirement plans and going to Timbuktu to make Disciple.”

He took a drink and continued.

“David, we need a plan to get the Disciples focused on the important things again.  I think we’ve let in too many people who are not truly dedicated to The Lord.


“It’s time to thin the heard so to speak.”  


Two notes:
1) This is a work of fiction.  Names, characters, and events are the product of the author's imagination; any resemblance to actual persons living or dead is purely coincidental.  To the best of my knowledge no organization called "The Word of God Foundation" exists.

2) comments are invited.  Publication of comments is subject to moderation.  If you wish to comment, but do not want your remarks made public, please include a note to that effect.  

Saturday, September 21, 2013

Armageddon's Prisoners 2

Jack’s nose still bled two hour after he got home, nothing helped.  He’d plugged with tissue, pinched the bridge of his nose, applied ice; the blood did not stop.  Now his neck hurt and he had a headache.

“Dad, you look terrible,” JJ asked, concern in his voice, “I think you should see a doctor.”

Jack looked up from where he lay on the couch.  JJ looked fuzzy and kept trying to turn into two people.

“I’m not sure I can see well enough to see a doctor.”

“Bad joke, your eyes are swelling shut.”

After a few minutes of discussion Jack let his son talk him into going to a drop in clinic a few blocks away.  Sally wasn’t answering her cell phone, probably indicating she’d joined a group in Disciple-making, the groups public preaching work.  As JJ drove him to the clinic, Jack fumed internally.  He wouldn’t say anything to his son, but it annoyed him that his wife put saving Outsiders ahead of checking on her husband.
The doctor poked and prodded, made noises and asking questions.  Jack thought some questions were none of the doctors business and refused to answer them.  The staff took an X-ray, after examining it, the doctor concluded that Jack’s nose was broken, but the headache wasn’t serious.

“Mr. Thornton,” he intoned, “I know you don’t think some of my questions are any of my business, in this business we get pretty good at putting puzzles together.”

Jack sat silently.  After a moment the man continued.

“I’m curious, what kind of church service involves fist fights.”

“I’d rather not answer, and it isn’t a church service.”

The doctor nodded, “so you’re a Disciple.”

“Well… yes,” Jack spoke hesitantly, he didn’t want to say or do anything that would give an Outsider a reason to criticize The Lord’s Word.  Then it occurred to him that he’d done nothing wrong.

“A couple of guys got mad, and it got out of hand. I’ve never seen anything like it.”
Jack left the clinic with a bottle of pain pills and tape on his nose.  He felt foolish and his head still hurt.  The reception when they arrived at home didn’t help.  When they came through the door Sally looked up from reading a Bible study aid.

“What is that on your face?”

“My nose is broken.”

“You should have stayed out of that stupid fight.”

Jack explained that he didn’t think he’d been in a fight, he’d been trying to stop one.  Sally ignored the remark, turning back to her study.  After a thirty seconds of dead silence, Jack said he had a headache and wanted to lie down.  Sally continued to ignore him.  Jack turned and walked silently to the bedroom and lay down.

“So what does she think I should have done,” he said to the ceiling.

Jack woke up with a start.  The pain pills must have done their job, a glance at the clock told him he’d slept for two hours.  Although the headache had dissipated, he still felt lousy.  He walked to the kitchen where Sally was sautéing onions.

“Smells good.”

She stirred the pan vigorously without answering. Pulling a can from the cupboard she slammed it on the counter, utensils rattled as she yanked a drawer open to find the can opener.

 “What did I do?” Jack snapped.

Sally took a deep sighing breath before answering through clenched teeth.

“I can’t believe you got in a fight at the Gathering House. Everybody is talking about it.  And your name keeps coming up.  You’ve humiliated me in front of all our friends.”

Jack protested the unfairness of the remark.  He’d only wanted to calm down the situation, to defuse the argument.  Arnie and Isaac were the ones in trouble.

“Well, you know they’re going to appoint a review committee, they’re going to ask you questions.  They could even remove you as a Servant, it’s a major setback for our standing in The Word.”

Jack didn’t see how they could have grounds to do that.  But he didn’t see any point in continuing to argue with Sally as long as her mood continued.  He turned toward the living room, maybe he could find a ball game or something on TV.

“Matt Kesselring called,” she said as he walked out of the kitchen, “I told you they’re setting up a committee.”

Jack flopped onto the couch, pulled out his cell phone called Kesselring, the current chairman of the Servant body. Matt answered immediately and asked Jack how he was feeling.

“Terrible.  Arnie broke my nose, I’m in pain and the trip to the clinic cost me three hundred and fifty bucks.”

“That’s too bad,” Matt said, sounding sympathetic for a few seconds, “I’m trying to organized a committee 
to look into what’s going on with those two kids. I could use your help.”

Matt’s comments left Jack nonplussed, “What about Arnie and Isaac?”

“Well, we don’t have any instructions in the manual for such a situation, so we had to kick it to New Jerusalem.  In the meantime we’ll look into our problem with the teenagers.  It probably isn’t just those two.”
Jack sighed.  As a Servant, the Word required him to help take the lead in keeping up Godly standards.  But sometimes, it just sounded ridiculous.  In reality, “New Jerusalem” meant the twelve Apostles at the world headquarters across the lake in Seattle.  It seemed silly to involve the leaders of four million Disciples in a fight between angry dads.  But eventually New Jerusalem settled all questions.

“Ok, but give me a day or two to recover.”

Later that evening, as he and Sally prepared for bed, she continued with the silent treatment. For a moment, fear gripped Jack.  If New Jerusalem, or even the other servants, thought he acted incorrectly, he would be Cast-out.  No one would even speak to him.  This would be his life.

“Sally, I was just trying to stop that fight.”

She sighed, “My cousin called, they already heard about it in Spokane.”

Jack wasn’t surprised.  Shari Covington having lived in the area for many years, had numerous contacts.  
She was also the biggest gossip in North America.  He decided to just give up for the day and climbed into bed.

 Sally flipped out the lamp as soon as Jack was in bed, and turned facing away from him.  Then she rolled back for a moment.

“I don’t understand why you think it’s odd that Matt wanted to call the Apostles.  They are our spiritual leaders, The Lord speaks through them.  Of course they will know what to do.”

“You’re right I guess.”

Jack didn’t really think she was, but his head hurt again and he wanted to go to sleep.  He would say anything at the moment to kill a late night pillow talk session.


“Good, you’ll see, they will provide the direction the Gathering needs to move past this and promote The Lord’s will.” 

Sunday, September 15, 2013

Armageddon's Prisoners 1

Jack Thornton suppressed a yawn, not wanting to look disrespectful of the Lord’s Word.  But the temperature inside the Gathering House rose with the summer sun outside.  The austere, windowless building had fans, but no air-conditioning.  This did not pose a hardship on most Seattle Sunday mornings.  The fact that he’d heard this morning’s Message, or one just like it, hundreds of times did not make staying awake any easier.

Jack, his wife Sally, and seventeen-year-old Jack Junior occupied their usual seats on the outside of the left hand aisle, halfway down.  He didn’t think anything of it when he heard Arnold Senge get up from the seat behind him.  His assumption that Arnie was heading to the men’s room dissolved when Arnie started shouting at the speaker, Isaac Taylor.

“How can you stand up there and lecture us about raising fine children when that brat of yours is always chasing after my daughter.”

“Maybe you should tell your daughter to stop encouraging him,” Taylor shouted.

“My daughter,” Senge yelled, “is a good Disciple.  She knows how to act around the opposite sex, unlike that pervert son of yours.”

Jack heard gasps from the rest of the audience. Issac’s face turned red. Jack stood up intending to tell Arnie to sit down and be quiet, they could talk about it after the Gathering ended.

Issac shouted something about Martha Senge being a tramp and stepped off the raised speaker’s platform.  Arnie started toward Taylor, pushing Jack out of the way when he tried to block the aisle.  Jack realized he needed to do something, the two men were only a few steps from each other.  He looked for the other Servants, none was close enough to get to the two men before they reached each other.  The rest of the Gathering sat in stunned disbelief.  Disciples didn’t get into fights.

“Arnie, let’s take this…”

Jack never finished the sentence.  Already unbalanced by the push, Arnie’s fist knocked him into Sally’s lap.  Sally screamed as blood from her husband’s nose sprayed her blouse.

An older Disciple tried to block Taylor’s path, who rudely pushed him out of the way.  Jack waved his arms and legs, trying to get up and feeling like a turtle on its back.  Before anyone else could react, Taylor and Senge collided in the aisle and started throwing punches at each other. 

As he struggled to stand up, Jack thought he heard JJ laugh.  When he did gain his feet he saw why.  Two middle aged, balding, sweating men in suits throwing badly aimed punches at each other made a ridiculous sight.  Larry McKinnon, one of the Gathering’s other Servants, jumped between the two men.

“Stop this you idiots,” he snapped, “this is The Lord’s House.”

A big burly man, Larry pushed between the two fighters and shoved them apart.  Matt Kesselring, coming up the aisle behind Jack got his arms around Arnie Senge, and pulled him back.  Todd Davis came around the front of the House and pulled Isaac Taylor back.  Larry, always known for his jovial personality, managed to find his sense of humor again.

“When was the last time either of you knuckleheads was in a fight?  Fifth grade?  Come on, let’s go to the library and talk about this.”

Larry and Todd pushed the two men toward the small library at the back end of the auditorium.  Somebody suggested to Jack that he clean up.  The rest of the congregation looked perplexed.  Nothing in their experience told them how to act after such an event.

“Who’s going to finish the Sunday morning message?” Travis Wilson asked.

“I think,” Matt responded, “that we should skip the rest of it and just go into the Study.”

“I don’t think we can just skip part of the Lord’s Gathering…”

“Look,” Matt said sharply, “you’re not a Servant, just an assistant.  In special circumstances, we can skip a Gathering if we have to.  Now go sit down.”

Jack, holding his handkerchief to his nose told his wife he thought he needed to get home. 

“I don’t want to miss the rest of Gathering,” she answered, “I can get a ride home with Sarah Davis.”

“Dad, I’ll drive you home,”  JJ said helpfully, as he tried, and failed, to look like he’d rather stay.

“Thanks, let’s go.”

“Well,” Jack said a moment later as he slammed the car door shut, “I have to admit that was more interesting than our usual Gathering.”

JJ laughed, “do those guys realize how stupid they look?”

“They did, didn’t they?  JJ, do you know anything about what’s going on between Martha Senge and Frank Taylor?”

JJ pursed his lips as he pulled out of the House parking lot onto the arterial.  Jack realized his son knew something and didn’t want to talk about it.

“JJ, I’m sure there will be Servants meetings about this.  I’d like to know what’s going on, but I promise you 

I won’t tell anybody where I get the information.”

“I thought the Servants are always totally honest with each other.”

JJ looked like he did not expect his father to keep a promise of confidentiality.  Servants had a habit of poking their noses into other people’s business no matter what the actual rules said. 

“Some man-made rules don’t need to be followed, my family comes first.”

JJ shrugged, “they’re both lying to their parents, she calls him, he goes over to see her.  They don’t care what the Foundation tells them to do.  Or not do.  After what happened two years ago, lots of u… lots of kids don’t care about the Word.  They talked up 2011 for as long as I can remember, and nothing happened.”

Jack sat in silent thought for several minutes.  What could he say? For a dozen years, The Word of God Foundation told its Disciples to expect the great Day of the Lord in 2011.  There had been nothing but trouble since that year came and went.  His own son now had doubts about The Word’s message. He mulled over several responses suggested by the Foundation and rejected all of them.  How could he say something he didn’t believe to his son? Before he could say anything more JJ broke the silence.

“Dad, as long as I have you here without Mom, I need to talk about something.”

“What?”

“I’m going to graduate in a little over a year.  I want to go to college.  I know the Word says it’s a waste of time with Paradise coming so soon and all, but it didn’t show up when they said it would, why should I believe them now?”

“JJ, I can’t say that I blame you for having doubts.”

He paused, gathering his thoughts and strength.  He’d never said what he was about to say aloud.


“I have my own doubts.  Stuff like what we just saw doesn’t help.  I won’t say no but let me think about it.” 

Saturday, September 7, 2013

Thoughts on the Convention, and a change of direction

I have decided to take a break from my reviews of this summer’s District Convention.  I listened to several talks since my last post.  What I heard was too simplistic to analyze in detail. I may try again soon, but another idea has grabbed my attention.

I’ve formed an overall impression of the current state of the Watchtower.  The Governing Body built a trap and caught themselves.  Listening to the convention talks, I realized how formulaic they sound: here is a question, here is the answer.  Rather than provide its membership with the tools they need to examine the Bible and express themselves on matters of conscience, the speakers provide endless Talmudic rules on specific issues.

Of course, the Watchtower cannot provide such training, its followers would see the logical flaws and factual errors in the Society’s publications.  For decades, the Governing Body declared itself the final judge of all religious matters.  They must now pass judgment on every matter, nothing remains for individual decision.    

Additionally, I think that Watchtower leadership has, consciously or unconsciously, abandoned the idea of making converts of nonWitnesses.  By this I don’t mean abandoning the door-to-door ministry.  That activity serves a useful purpose in keeping the flock busy and providing a source of self-identification.  The convention program seems aimed entirely at an internal audience.  Talks disparaging education, career involvement and limiting contact with nonWitnesses will not attract any reasonable nonbeliever.  These subjects to reinforce Watchtower culture to the conventions attendees.

As I said, I do not know if this is intentional.  The Watchtower leadership now focuses on controlling its members, while living in its own world.  They do not understand the effects of their words on the public.  Or perhaps they simply don’t care. 
A new 250 acre headquarters compound is under construction in upstate New York.  I will be watching this project with interest. It is bigger than anything the Society needs for administrative purposes.  It looks like it might be a good place to retire. 


I decided last night to reassemble the pieces of another novel I started for last year’s NaNoWriMo.  I’m going to serialize a chapter a week, starting Sunday the fifteenth.  I need to impose some order on my writing efforts and this seems like a good way to get going. 

Thursday, August 1, 2013

Chairman’s Address: How We Know God’s Word Is Truth.


The Chairman’s address is the first talk convention attendees hear.  I would think they would want to start the program with a bang, and fire up the audience about what they will learn over the next three days.
I’ve tried three times to listen to this talk, I managed to do get through it only by fast-forwarding in places.  It is insipid, uninspiring, shallow, and illogical, dull as dishwater.  I know, that’s a cliché, but it’s difficult to explain how boring this speech is. 

According to the speaker, the Truth is immutable, it does not change. There can be only one truth. The speaker points out many books claim to be the inspired word of God, to be “the Truth.”  He sets out to prove the Bible is the only book that correctly makes that claim.

Jehovah’s Witnesses have a problem in this discussion, the innumerable times they have changed doctrine and prophetic interpretation.  They try to explain this with the idea of “progressive interpretation,” the truth does not change; our understanding of it does.  Scriptural support for this idea is based on Proverbs 4:18, “But the path of the righteous ones is like the bright light that is getting lighter and lighter until the day is firmly established.” (New World Translation)

I have been unable to find any nonWatchtower commentary that supports the Jehovah’s Witness interpretation of this scripture.  Witnesses believe this verse supports the idea that God will reveal “new light,” new interpretations of scripture as it suits Him.  All other commentators, reading the verse in context say it describes the growth of an individual, not organizational changes.

Given the Watchtowers habit of altering its interpretations, it needs some a scriptural fig leaf to cover its errors.    

After skating past the Watchtower Society abysmal track record on advancing “truth that does not change” the speaker lists several “proofs” the Bible is “the truth.”  This part of the talk sounds like something written by an earnest sixth grader.  Among these proofs are:
-   The Bible describes the earth as a sphere long before astronauts went to space and saw this. 
-   A prophecy that the city of Babylon would never be rebuilt has proven true.
-   The Bible predicts that Satan would kill Jesus and sure enough, he did.

This talk does not merit more attention, and I could not bring myself to listen to more of it.  I am formulating a theory about the current state of the Watchtower.  This talk supports my ideas, which will be presented in due time.


I have been away from this blog.  I did not intend to take this much time between posts.  However, I was working hard on a special project – editing a manuscript in preparation for submission to a publisher.  Looking at every single work in four hundred seventy page manuscript occupied my full attention.  You’ll hear more about that project at the appropriate time. 


Friday, July 5, 2013

Keynote Address: Follow the Governing Body

A keynote speech sets the tone for an event, laying the foundation for the main points of discussion or an underlying theme; outlining core ideas and key pieces of information.  Americans are most familiar with the keynote speeches given at political conventions.  No matter what one thinks of his position on the issues, everyone recognizes that Barack Obama’s 2004 keynote address propelled him onto the national stage and into the Oval Office four years later.

Giving a district convention keynote address will never propel a Jehovah’s Witness anywhere.  Like the use of the term symposium, Jehovah’s Witness conventions feature a “keynote address.”  This year’s keynote address (I have not listened to one since 1988) offers a revealing look at the Governing Body’s thinking.

The talk starts with a description of the Temple of Artemis in Ephesus, with huge columns supporting the roof.  The speaker quotes 1 Tim 3:14-15 “Although I hope to come to you soon, I am writing you these instructions so that, if I am delayed, you will know how people ought to conduct themselves in God’s household, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth.” 

“Like a pillar, the congregation of God holds the truth up,” by preaching, supporting the organization, and maintaining good conduct. This talk does not say much about preaching.  Organizational refinements support the truth (the Organization), and enable Witnesses to become better Christians, it lists ten.  These are

1) A separate study edition of the Watchtower
2) Introduction of a public edition of the magazine
3) Reduction of the Awake magazine to sixteen pages
4) Combining midweek meetings, leaving a night free for personal or family study.
5) Arrangement for Pioneers (full-time preachers) to attend the Pioneer school twice
6) A Bible School for Christian couples
7) Greater use of audio and video productions
8) A redesigned website
9) Expanded efforts at preaching in Public places
10) New “Research Guide for Jehovah’s Witnesses

My comments:

The “study” edition of the Watchtower originated after an article on disfellowshipped family members produced negative publicity (family members aren’t supposed to talk to them).  Apparently, somebody figured out the need to keep some aspects of the religion out of public view.

The smaller Awake magazine is almost certainly a cost cutting measure.  I don’t know what the School for Christian couples entails.  If you’ve attended one, I’d like to hear about it.

Item four, “family study night” featured an interesting speaker comment.  He stated that many Witnesses expressed frustration at lack of time for personal or family study.  “Well, the Governing Body heard you” and cut out one night of meetings each week.  Funny, I thought the Governing Body listened to, and passed along God’s instructions. 

The last item, including demonstrations of its use, took up about one third of the talk.  It is a “simplified” reference list of Watchtower articles on various subjects.  “Simplified” means “most recent.”   In other words, it helps hide older, incorrect information.

The discussion then moves to a “Christian” (JW) duty to uphold the truth, through good conduct. It includes demonstrations on using the new Research Guide to determine, for example, how to dress for the convention. It also provides information showing why “worldly” dancing is bad.

The address ended by calling the congregation a “bulwark against false teaching” and encourages Witnesses to “be determined to keep working in harmony with the congregation.”

Several thoughts stuck me in listening to this.  I did not once hear the name Jesus.  There is no mention of Jehovah except indirectly, for example when speaking of “Jehovah’s Organization.”  In a talk that ran about half an hour, I only counted seven scripture references. 

The talk focused entirely on the Watchtower organization and its writings. In discussing good conduct, the talk demonstrates researching through Watchtower publications, not the Bible, to answer questions.  Nowhere does there appear to be room for conscience or individuality.  The Governing Body serves as final authority in even the most mundane matters.

I believe the Watchtower intended this talk for an “in-house” audience. People with no prior connection to Watchtower may be put off, offended, or disturbed by its content.  The overall impression it gives is that in Watchtower theology, the Bible, Jesus and even Jehovah, are subordinate to the Governing Body.


Wednesday, June 26, 2013

District Convention Symposium “Reject What is False!

I have attended many scholarly conferences over the years, including scientific, religious and industry group gatherings.  I sat through fifteen years of Watchtower Society conventions of various sizes.  Contrasting the differences between the Watchtower’s convention methods and the standards of an academic conference is in order.  Typically, organizers of an academic conference issue a call for papers.  Independent researchers submit their work and a committee chooses those they think best represent their planned meeting.  At such a conference, multiple sessions occur at the same time, participants select what they want to hear. 

“Symposiums,” consist of shorter presentations on related subjects.  Frequently, several symposiums occur at the same time, convention participants pick the ones they want to hear.  The program usually includes time for question and answer sessions with presenters.

Watchtower conventions appear to follow this format, but this is deceitful.  The Watchtower’s leadership produces all information, speakers read the material from manuscripts.  In fact, observers follow every presentation to catch any deviation.  All convention “delegates” hear all the information.  Separate sessions, and question and answer periods do not take place.  The Watchtower has grown fond of the word symposium, although their version does not follow the typical academic format.      

Nevertheless, Witnesses treat these events as important occasions.  Many travel hundreds of miles to hear the program.  In the past, the summer “district conventions” lasted four or five days with thousands present. Current events are shorter and smaller. The use of terms like “keynote address” and “symposium” in the program provide a veneer of scholarly work.  Speaker introductions feature proud listing of their credentials as Witnesses, which hides the scripted nature of the performance they deliver. 

I now have, and will review, audio of most of this year’s program. I expect to make several posts at least providing my analysis of the speeches. My review starts with the first symposium presented on Saturday, just because it follows up on my last post so well.  Under the title “Reject What is False!”  The symposium consists of four talks, each about ten minutes long.

The first, “False Gods” contained a common theme in Watchtower literature.  It takes several scriptures about God and applies them to the Watchtower Society.  For example, both Hebrews 3:12,13 “See to it, brothers and sisters, that none of you has a sinful, unbelieving heart that turns away from the living God,” and Psalm 86:11 “Teach me your way, Lord, that I may rely on your faithfulness; give me an undivided heart, that I may fear your name,” are applied to accepting Watchtower teachings as an article of faith.  In other words, anything from non-watchtower sources is wrong.

The last part of this talk struck me as funny in light of what I wrote in my last entry. It ended with a dramatization of a Witness studying an unnamed publication.  He turns off his internet to avoid distractions.  Yes, don’t let the greatest pool of knowledge in human history distract you from your research!  See my previous post about deliberate ignorance.

The next brief talk concerns “False Hopes.”  From the title, I expected a discussion of false prophecy. Instead, the “false hopes” discussed center on hoping to get away with violating Jehovah’s (the Watchtower’s) standards.  This talk features a dramatization of a single sister turning down a dinner invitation from a non-witness co-worker she apparently likes.  Can’t have any association with “worldly” people.
Part three, “A False Front” highlighted the Bible’s condemnation of hypocrisy and false faith.  The material, while simplistic, at least covered a worthwhile topic.  However, the message apparently has not reached the right target.  If the Watchtower intends to curb a two-faced attitude among its followers, it needs to correct the problem at the top.

The Watchtower counsels its members to avoid material pursuits and concentrate on the impending destruction of the world.  Meanwhile, construction continues on a multi-million dollar, 253 acre administrative complex in Warwick, NY.  While touting the cleanliness of its congregation, the Watchtower attempts to cover up a major pedophile problem within the organization and pays out millions in settlement claims.  The Watchtower leadership has its own problem with a “false front.”

The final talk is “The False Stylus.”  There is a brief discussion of Jeremiah 8:8.9 which speaks of men using a false stylus to circulate wrong teachings.  In the first few minutes of the speaker states that dishonesty is rampant in the world, and paints the media as spreading false information, as opposed to always honest Witnesses.  The talk then turns into a lengthy discussion of keeping integrity in personal affairs, and provides a demonstration of witness business owner debating, and then rejecting the idea of cheating on a contract.
Throughout listening to this symposium something struck me as odd, I did not fully grasp it until listening to the fourth segment.  I expected some in-depth scriptural and theological information.  Instead, we are treaty to simplistic and shallow reasoning about ignoring outside information sources, and staying away from relationships outside the witnesses.  While listening to the second half of the symposium I realized what was wrong.

I thought a talk about protection from dishonesty in business to explore recognizing that someone is cheating you.  Then it struck me the Watchtower can’t instruct its members in such methods, they might apply the analytical techniques to the Watchtower itself! Within weeks of starting our independent research, my wife and I began the process of mentally leaving the religion.  A Witness, with moderate training in recognizing propaganda espousing a false hope, might quickly connect the dots in promises that college education is unnecessary because the end of the world is coming. 


This is the first time in years I’ve listened to a District Convention part in full.  It is obvious these events subtract from, rather than adding to, the knowledge of the Jehovah’s Witness flock.  


Thursday, June 6, 2013

You can lead an ignorant person to a library, but you can’t make him read a book.

I do not fault anyone for lack of education or knowledge., We cannot know everything.  However, we can always be willing to learn; willing to examine new facts, and consider differing points of view.  Refusal to challenge our own assumptions, to reevaluate what we think we know is willful ignorance.   

An abundance of information exists to support the idea that Jehovah’s Witnesses do not teach “the truth.”  As noted in an earlier post, I did my earliest research on the Watchtower at the public library.  The dozen or so volumes available to me proved sufficient to convince me to leave the religion.  That was in 1988.  Today the internet provides more information than anyone can absorb.  Typing “Jehovah’s Witnesses” into Bing produced nearly three million results.  “Jehovah’s Witnesses errors” produced 945,000.  While doing my library research, I constantly watched over my shoulder in irrational fear of discovery.  An internet search takes place in the privacy of one’s own home. 

The Watchtower Bible and Tract Society elevates willful ignorance to a moral and educational virtue by discouraging such searches. My own experience provides an excellent example.

In 1979, the Watchtower magazine printed two statements on the nature of Jesus’ relationship to His disciples.  The first, a short “Questions from Readers” comment in the April 1st edition stated, “Jesus is the ‘mediator’ only for anointed Christians.”  The November 15th issue carried a seven-page study article “Benefiting from ‘One Mediator Between God And Men’ that elaborated on this theme.  According to this article the “great crowd” of nonanointed Jehovah’s Witnesses benefit from Jesus’ role as mediator by associating with the anointed class.

At the time, I did not appreciate the full implications of these articles.  In fact, I don’t remember studying them at all.  I did not grasp the significance of this information until I began my independent research eleven years later.  So for ten years, I lived in willful ignorance of my own religions true teachings. Contrary to published Watchtower doctrine, I believed Jesus was my mediator with God. 

I’m not alone in this.  A few years ago, two Jehovah’s Witnesses knocked on my door.  From their age and manner, I believe they were Elders.  I told them that as a Christian, I could not believe a religion that taught that Jesus was only the mediator for a small group of people.  They told me the Watchtower did not teach that.  My response “when did that change?” confused them.  I told them to look up the 1979 articles and come see me again.  They never came back.

For many years, I lived in willful ignorance of the history and teachings of my religion.  Breaking free of that ignorance took time, hard work, and a willingness to challenge my own assumptions.  Some people, caught up in high-control groups seem unable make the effort.  Some people eventually do break loose from the bonds that hold their minds.  Having made the journey, I will encourage them whenever possible. 



A note about future posts. This post started as an analysis of information from this year’s District Convention Program, the content of which got me to thinking about willful ignorance.  I intend to launch a detailed review of the Convention program.  Stay tuned!            

Monday, May 27, 2013

Thinking about my relationship with the Watchtower


 I just spent almost two weeks on the road.  My wife and I drove to Boulder, Colorado to watch our daughter receive her Master’s degree.  Wife flew home the next day and I stayed two more days to help the daughter with a startup business.  I then spent three days alone in the car getting home.  (Trip totaled 3168 miles in about 10 days).  Driving to Boulder provided opportunity to talk. We spent much of the drive discussing family, our lives together, work, and a host of other subjects.  Naturally, this led to some interesting conversation about the present state of our religious beliefs.  The trip home alone provided an opportunity to think about it all.  I have some new ideas to work into my stories.

So today’s entry is about what I want to accomplish by writing about cult-like groups, and why I think it is important.  In brief, I have no set religious beliefs, at least none I feel compelled to convince others to believe with me.  My wife and I agree that we cannot define one belief superior to another, and that most of them look like schemes to rake in money.     

If you look in the “cult” section of a Christian bookstore you will find many volumes analyzing the doctrinal mistakes of a host of religions, among them Jehovah’s Witness, Mormons, Scientologists and many others.  For example, I have on my shelf “Encyclopedia of Cults and New Religions” by John Ankerberg and John Weldon.  This work lists fifty-seven groups the authors consider cults, or cult-like.  This book, like many similar volumes, focuses on issues of doctrine.

To put it bluntly, I don’t care what people believe.  If you want to think the Great Pumpkin will rise out of the most sincere pumpkin patch in the world, that is your choice and I see no need to argue with you.  I care a lot if you are blindly following a course that will damage you, or your loved ones.  I consider it my moral duty to provide information and sound a warning.  I think, far too many people have lived damaged lives or incomplete lives because they surrendered their critical thinking to some group.

My wife and I recalled old friends, people who no longer speak to us because we left the religion.  Forty years ago, we expected the world to end.  Today, these friends still expect the end of the world “soon.”  They have never lived up to their full potential because they lived their lives on hold. Everything good would happen in the New System. 

I do not think this problem lies solely with Jehovah’s Witnesses or even religion generally.  Political movements of all stripes display some of the negative traits of high control groups.  The same holds true for many multilevel marketing programs.  These organizations compel the individual to give up freedom of action and conscience for group-think.  I believe that this reduces the individuals need and right to enjoy life to the fullest.  When we give up self-fulfillment to group-think we lose a piece of ourselves. 

So my purpose is educational, to provoke thought not provide answers.  I do not seek to gather followers, in fact the exact opposite.  (This summer’s Watchtower conventions apparently contain a long talk on people like me trying to recruit followers, I’ll comment on that in another post.)  The idea of attracting “followers” is the exact antithesis of my beliefs.  Nor do I want to “bring down the Watchtower.” 


I want people to think for themselves.  I hope to help them do so.  

Sunday, April 28, 2013

The Watchtower Memory Hole


The ruling elite in George Orwell’s 1984 carefully manage facts about their history to insure compliance with current statements about itself.  The protagonist, Winston Smith, makes his living destroying inconvenient documents by dumping them down the “memory hole.”  Somebody at Watchtower headquarters now has Winston’s job, altering the past to comply with the Governing Body’s current version of its history. 

I first uncovered proof of this while doing the research that led to my break with the religion.  Here I will present two examples from the 1975 Yearbook of Jehovah’s Witnesses (Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society, 1974). 

In September 1922 J. F. Rutherford, President of the Watchtower Society deliver a stirring speech to a convention in Cedar Point, Ohio.  During the time I was a Witness, we heard the rousing conclusion, “Advertise, advertise, advertise, the King and his kingdom” many times.  The Yearbook contained this quote (page 131) from the speech:
“… Since 1914 the King of glory has taken his power and reigns.  He has cleansed the lips of the temple class and sends them forth with the message.  The importance of the message of the kingdom cannot be overstated.  It is the message of all messages.  It is the message of the hour.  It is incumbent upon those who are the Lord’s to declare it.  The Kingdom of heaven is at hand; the King reigns; Satan’s empire is falling; millions now living will never die.
“Do you believe it?...”

The book quotes another paragraph that leads to the ending statement noted above.  I never gave much thought to the ellipsis until I began researching in 1988.  I then discovered a more complete text of the speech in “Crisis of Conscience” by Ray Franz (Commentary Press, Atlanta, GA 1983).  Franz notes (pages 189-190) the speech included references to the time of the end beginning in 1799 and Jesus second presence dating from 1874.  Immediately after asking, “Do you believe it?” Rutherford said “Do you believe that the King of glory has been present since 1874?”

A Witness reading this today, or as I did in 1988, would answer “no, I do not believe that.”  For obvious reasons, the Watchtower did not want to include the full quote.

The yearbook noted J. F. Rutherford’s (the second President of the Watch Tower Society) failing health in the 1940’s.  According to this account, Rutherford needed to transfer from New York to a warmer climate.  Witnesses had contributed to the purchase of a house for his benefit.  The Yearbook quotes the 1939 book Salvation:
“At San Diego, California there is a small piece of land, on which, in the year 1929 was a built a house, which is called and known as Beth-Sarim.” (p194)

Seventy pages before this, the Yearbook discussed the campaign centered on a message that “millions now living will never die.”  The “millions” campaign centered on the expected resurrection of Old Testament luminaries such as Moses, Abraham, Isaac, Noah, David and others in the year 1925.  Here is the complete quote from Salvation:
“At San Diego, California, there is a small piece of land, on which, in the year 1929, there was built a house, which is called and known as Beth-Sarim. The Hebrew words Beth Sarim meaning "House of the Princes"; and the purpose of acquiring that property and building the house was that there might be some tangible proof that there are those on earth today who fully believe God and Christ Jesus and in His kingdom, and who believe that the faithful men of old will soon be resurrected by the Lord, be back on earth, and take charge of the visible affairs of earth. The title to Beth-Sarim is vested in the WATCH TOWER BIBLE & TRACT SOCIETY in trust, to be used by the president of the Society and his assistants for the present, and thereafter be forever at the disposal of the aforementioned princes on the earth. To be sure, everything then on the earth will belong to the Lord, and neither the Lord nor the princes need others to build houses for them; but it was thought well and pleasing to God that the afore mentioned house be built as a testimony to the name of Jehovah and showing faith in his announced purposes. The house has served as a testimony to many persons throughout the earth, and while the unbelievers have mocked concerning it and spoken contemptuously of it, yet it stands there as a testimony to Jehovah's name; and if and when the princes do return and some of them occupy the property, such will be a confirmation of the faith and hope that induced the building of Beth-Sarim.”  (p311)

 When I discovered the difference between the quotes and the original material, I decided I had caught the Watchtower in an outright lie.  The society does not admit to prior errors in teaching.  The writers of the Yearbook clearly understood the problems the full quotes create. So the information went down the memory hole.  I am firmly convinced those writers knew exactly what they were doing.

The book “Jehovah’s Witness, Proclaimers of God’s Kingdom” (Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society, 1993) mentions the controversy briefly on page 76.  However, it downplays the central role Beth-Sarim played in Watchtower prophecy during the 1920’s and 1930’s.  This account emphasizes Beth-Sarim as Rutherford’s residence, which may be closer to the truth of the matter.

I intend to continue my research with regard to how the Watchtower quotes itself. These two examples, I believe, are sufficient to demonstrate that upper management of the Watchtower organization knows that it has major problems with its claim to be the mouthpiece of Jehovah.    

Saturday, April 13, 2013

Informed Consent


“Informed consent” is a common phrase in medicine and related law.  The term means a patient knows all relevant facts and is mentally capable of making decisions about his or her care. (see Wikipedia.com “Informed Consent”)

This article examines informed consent in a religious context.  When Jehovah’s Witnesses, decide matters of finances, education, medical treatment, or even whether to join the religion; do they have all the information they need to make that decision? Do they have the clear mental facilities needed to decide?

I will submit that they do not.

BLOOD

The Watchtower’s position on the use of blood provides an excellent starting point regarding informed consent.  Do Jehovah’s Witnesses have the information they need to understand the issue?  More importantly, do they clearly appreciate the matter and understand the future implication of their decision? 
Officially, Jehovah’s Witnesses base their decision on a narrow reading of Acts 15:29 which commands Christians to “abstain” from blood.  The Watchtower Society interprets this to include using blood for medical reasons. Officially, refusal of blood transfusions is a purely religious decision.  However, Witnesses believe that their position has a solid grounding in science. 

A review of entries under “Blood” in the “Index of Watchtower Publications” (http://wol.jw.org/en/wol/d/r1/lp-e/1200270859) shows dozens of articles relating supposed evidence of the dangers of blood transfusions.  The number of articles directly related to the religious issues involved is much smaller.  Watchtower publications do not provide any statistical analysis of the dangers of blood transfusion versus the dangers of refusing medically necessary treatment.  This is, of course, the only scientifically valid means of assessing the risks of the procedure. 

For example the June 15, 2000 Watchtower, in a “Questions from Readers” article states “Today, most transfusions are not of whole blood but of one of its primary components: (1) red cells; (2) white cells; (3) platelets; (4) plasma (serum), the fluid part. Depending on the condition of the patient, physicians might prescribe red cells, white cells, platelets, or plasma. Transfusing these major components allows a single unit of blood to be divided among more patients. Jehovah’s Witnesses hold that accepting whole blood or any of those four primary components violates God’s law. Significantly, keeping to this Bible-based position has protected them from many risks, including such diseases as hepatitis and AIDS that can be contracted from blood.”

Note the article provides no information about the relative dangers of contracting AIDS or not accepting the transfusion.  Based on this information only, a Witness may conclude that medical science believes that refusing blood is a safe alternative.    

Also noteworthy is dividing blood into major and minor components.  Modern medicine does not recognize this idea.  Many Witnesses do not understand this, and do not know the difference between allowable and forbidden blood products. For example, after the birth of our first child my wife decided to take a gamma globulin shot to treat an Rh incompatibility.  A few months earlier, a good friend nearly lost her second child because she had previously refused the same treatment because it contained blood products.  

In another example of distorted science a July 2008 issue of “Awake!” magazine reported that a Duke University study stated that “Blood transfusions with banked human blood may do more harm than good for a majority of patients.”   Typical of most articles in Watchtower publications this one contained no reference locating the original source of the quote.  A Google search revealed a Duke University press release on the subject. (http://olv.duke.edu/About/News/20071008112145282)   which contains this paragraph:
“Transfusions are still critically important, however. ‘Banked blood is truly a national treasure that needs to be protected,’ Stamler said. ‘Blood can be life saving, only it is not helping the way we had hoped and in many cases it may be making things worse. In principle, we now have a solution to the nitric oxide problem--we can put it back--but it needs to be proven in a clinical trial.’”

The Watchtower simply did not address this part of the report, which did not support its position.   The average Witnesses does not know that the Watchtower slanted the information and believes that a Duke University study supports his beliefs on blood transfusions.  In my opinion the Watchtower deliberately deceives its readers, rather than informing them of all relevant facts.

Remember that the Watchtower teaches its followers to rely on the Society’s publications over all other sources of information.  The Witnesses’ internal filters make a clear appreciation of the facts about blood impossible. In other words, even presentation of scientific evidence will not sway a Witness from refusing transfusion. Thus, although medical science does not recognize the Watchtower’s division of blood in major and minor components, Witnesses firmly believe there is a solid scientific basis for this reasoning.  This, in turn, leads to terrible decisions based on a faulty understanding of both the scientific and religious issues. 

The May 22, 1994 issue of the Awake! Magazine contains a truly heartbreaking article.  The cover of this magazine features this picture.

Only upon reading the article do we discover that these happy smiling children are all dead because they refused (or their parents refused for them) to accept life-saving blood transfusions.  To this picture, we can add the thousands of adult Witnesses who have blindly accepted the Watchtower’s teachings on reasonable medical treatments.

I can only rejoice that my wife and I never killed one of our children over this unfounded and unscientific doctrine.  

My next article will examine the Watchtower's slanted advice regarding education, and by extension, career choices.  

Monday, April 1, 2013


Genesis of a Cult



This snippet of backstory does not appear in either of my manuscripts.  I wrote it while trying to solidify some of the backstory.  Consider it part of the mythology my cult tells about itself.  You’ll hear the real story soon. 


Clifton Adderly walked north along Railroad Avenue.  He did not expect to find work, but one could hope.  Behind him, Seattle’s Hooverville covered the reclaimed tidal flats with flimsy shacks and despair.  He had no destination, seeking only to leave the squalor behind.  The hardware store he inherited from his father thrived in 1927, four years later, it died.  After a year of living in one of Hooverville’s shanties, Adderly longed for death, and cursed himself for a coward.  He longed for death, but could not take his own life.  He shuffled along, hating himself and wishing for a drink.

“Hey buddy, want to make a dollar?” A voice hissed out of the doorway of a closed hotel.

Adderly hesitated, the exorbitant wage meant something illegal or dangerous, probably both.  But money meant a drink, and a chance to escape his life.

“How?”

“Deliver a package for me.  I’ll give you a quarter, they’ll give you the rest when you get there.”

Adderly thought for only a second, he had not eaten in two days.

“OK.”

Shortly he walked east toward the Japanese and Chinese enclaves at the edge of downtown Seattle, a bulky envelope under his arm and a quarter in his pocket.  He made the delivery and collected his seventy-five cents.  The recipient offered him a tip, a shot of cheap whiskey.  Adderly took a drink, savoring the burning sensation in his throat.  The liquor warmed his body, eased his pain.  The man offered him another dollar to take back a second package.  Adderly agreed readily.

Soon he had a steady source of funds for his painkiller.  Three or four times a week he ran the packages back and forth, always he used the money for pain relief.  The emotional pain faded, eventually so did conscious thought.


He woke up with someone shaking him roughly.  Freezing rain filled his eyes and soaked his clothes.  He lay against a doorway and rubbed his eyes. Even with no light, he could see a Christmas tree in a store window across the street.
“When did it get to be Christmas?”

“About nineteen hundred years ago,” the man shaking him answered, “come with me, we’ll help you out.”

With assistance Adderly staggered to his feet.  His head hurt.  He reached for the flask he always carried in his coat pocket.  It was gone.

“I took that.  You want need it where we’re going.”

“Where are we going?”

“Salvation.  Paradise.”

Adderly let the man lead him to a nearby basement.  A huge picture of Jesus covered the far wall.

The next few days were a blur.  His benefactors fed him, gave him warm clothing, and kept him away from the bottle.  Every night they sat on the floor reading from the Bible and discussing the passages.  Adderly didn’t object, he couldn’t remember clearly when he’d last been warm, dry and fed.

“Who are you?” he asked.

They laughed as the answers came from around the room: “Mark, John, Peter, Mary, Joshua, Elizabeth, Timothy, Pricilla…”

“No,” Adderly objected, “I mean what church is this?”

“We have no name,” the man who called himself Peter said, “we are not a church.  We are just Disciples of God’s word.  We seek only to know what it is Adonai Elohim is trying to tell us through his word.”

“Adda what?”

“The Lord God.”

Adderly stayed in the no-name church because he had nowhere else to go.  He read their literature and studied their methods of interpretation.  One day they baptized him, immersing his body in a tub of water.  When he came they told him he had to decide on a new name for himself, one befitting The Lord Almighty’s new creation.

“Michael,” he said.

There was a hush, a few of his new friends even bowed their heads.

“I told you 1933 was a marked year,” Paul said, “and here he is, right on time.”


-   Excerpt from - Disciples through the Ages.  The Word of God Foundation, Seattle Washington, 1982